Hi,
One of my most important problem with HA is the reliability of the communication with all the devices.
I would like some watchdog feature in domotiga in order to overcome the lack of bidirectionnal communication and state resend with cheap X10 devices. Let me illustrate my thought
For example, i have a PIR detector (mS13), i sometimes miss the back to "no motion"signal so the domotiga state of the device stays "motion" for hours.... This can lead to some problems when there is some events related to the device state. The physical device state is inconsistent with domotiga device state, there is no way to read the physical device state. Lets note this Problem 1.
Another but different example : I have a event that turns off a lamp, if for any reason the device miss the message, domotiga believes the devices is off, but it is still on. (I still remember my huge electricity bill...) Once agin we have an inconsistent physical/domotiga device state. This is problem 2.
Problem 2 can be solved by adding a checkbox in the device editor with a label "resend state" ( a spinbox can also be added to configure the period)
Problem 1 can be solved by adding a checkbox in the device editor with a label "reset state to", with a user editable state, and a period.
What do you think about this?
Hplus
New features for cheap devices
Forum about Domotiga Open Source Home Automation for Linux.
Moderator: RDNZL
Jump to
- Forum matters
- ↳ News Forum
- ↳ Suggestions, Questions & Feedback
- Hardware Forum (English)
- ↳ Announcements & News Forum
- ↳ Questions & Discussions Forum
- ↳ Kickstarter, Indiegogo and other crowdfunding related smartthings
- ↳ Rfxcom Receivers & Transmitters Forum
- ↳ X10, A10 Xanura Marmitek Forum
- ↳ Z-Wave Forum
- ↳ Fibaro
- ↳ Plugwise Forum
- ↳ Gadgets Forum
- ↳ Visonic Alarm systems
- ↳ LEDS, DMX & Lights Forum
- ↳ Hvac, Heating Opentherm Forum
- ↳ Opentherm Gateway Forum
- ↳ Opentherm Gateway Forum (NL)
- ↳ Philips Pronto (TSU9600), IRtrans and other remotes
- ↳ Touchpanels, Displays & UMPC devices.
- ↳ 1-Wire Forum
- ↳ Click On Click Off & Home Easy
- ↳ Raspberry, Arduino, Cubietruck and other clones Forum
- ↳ Homematic, FS20, FHT, ESA and ELV
- ↳ PLCBUS Forum
- ↳ Smart Metering Forum
- ↳ ZigBee Forum
- ↳ Eneco Toon as Domotica controller
- Toon Thermostat Smart Home Automation controller (English)
- ↳ Toon news and information
- ↳ Manuals/tutorials
- ↳ Toon Apps
- ↳ Toon Rooting
- ↳ Toon Hardware
- ↳ Toon Firmware
- ↳ Toon external control
- ↳ Toon miscellaneous
- ↳ Toon software development
- ↳ Toon issues and support (Nederlands toegestaan)
- ↳ Toon wanted/for sale (Nederlands toegestaan)
- Software Forum (English)
- ↳ Announcements & News
- ↳ Questions & Discussions Forum
- ↳ Linux Forum
- ↳ Windows Forum
- ↳ DomotiGa Forum
- ↳ OpenHAB Forum
- ↳ MQTT & Node.js
- Projects Forum (English)
- ↳ Home Automation Projects
- ↳ Bwired Forum
- ↳ Who has a realtime website
- Homeseer Forum (Dutch Allowed)
- ↳ Homeseer algemeen Forum
- ↳ Homeseer Scripts Forum
- ↳ Homeseer HStouch Forum
- ↳ Homeseer Plugins Forum
- ↳ Homeseer Alphatronics Visonic receiver Plugin Forum
- ↳ Homeseer Buienradar monitor HS3 plugin
- ↳ Homeseer Fritz!box Plugin Forum
- ↳ Homeseer IPPower Plugin Forum
- ↳ Homeseer MQTT Plugin Forum
- ↳ Homeseer Nemef Radaris Evolution plugin Forum
- ↳ Homeseer P1 Smart Meter - Plugin HS3
- ↳ Homeseer Philips Hue - Plugin HS3
- ↳ Homeseer Plugwise Plugin Forum
- ↳ Homeseer PMIX35, CTX15, CTX35 - Plugin HS3
- ↳ Homeseer Rfxcom Plugin Forum
- ↳ Homeseer Thermostaat plug-in forum
- ↳ Homeseer Visonic Powermax plugin Forum
- ↳ Homeseer Xtreamer Plugin Forum
- Other (English)
- ↳ For Sale Forum (Dutch allowed)
- ↳ Miscellaneous Home Automation topics
- ↳ Security & Alarmpanels Forum
- ↳ Energycontrol & Home Automation Forum
- ↳ Webcams & Camera Stuff Forum
- ↳ Off Topic
- ↳ Downloads & Links Forum
- ↳ Domoticaboek Heino Peters
- ↳ Dealers Corner
- ↳ Domotica for Dummies Forum
- ↳ Groups purchases or -ideas
- ↳ Test